DVD-quality lessons (including tabs/sheet music) available for immediate viewing on any device.
Take your playing to the next level with the help of a local or online flatpicked guitar teacher.
Monthly newsletter includes free lessons, favorite member content, flatpicked guitar news and more.
The flatpicked guitar reviews database is here to help educate people before they purchase an instrument. Of course, this is not meant to be a substitute for playing the instrument yourself!
161 reviews in the archive.
Where Purchased: Guitar Center, Rochester NY
Year Purchased: 2008
Price Paid: 2400 ($US)
Unbelievable sound on this guitar. I am experimenting with various string-makers and all sound very good. It gets used extensively in the studio and I mic it with an AT 4041, and sometimes double-track with a Fathead Ribbon. As fro variety, it can sound like a killer or a weeper. Just depends on what and how you want to play.
Sound Rating: 9
Setup was good. Action good. No modifications were necessary.
Setup Rating: 10
Nice to look at. The rosewood is a deep reddish color. The sitka is aging nicely.
Appearance Rating: 9
Solid tuners, chrome. The bracing is good, can't see any weak spots.
Reliability Rating: 9
Dealt a few times for this and other guitars. They are always responsive, helpful, reasonably couteous. Not as good as Beard, but good.
Customer Service: 8
The parts are all good and solid. As for standing out otherwise, the tone, clarity and volume. If you need to to project, over some other instrument, it's quite simple-just pick harder.
Components Rating: 10
No issues with this at all. This is a lot of guitar.
Overall Rating: 10
Where Purchased: Used
Year Purchased: 2009
Price Paid: 1600 ($US) (bought USED)
Martin solid spruce/solid East Indian Rosewood, scalloped X brace, dovetail neck joint dreadnought. All these characteristics come together to produce the famous Martin sound. Distinctive loud, broad spectrum, well balanced authoritative tone from the low E on up. Well rounded tone that sounds great strummed, flatpicked, or fingerpicked. Some might call it boomy and bassy. Perhaps not a totally ideal flatpicking lead guitar, because of that, but it makes up for that in that it sounds great in any situation. It can hold its own anywhere in the hands of someone who knows how to light it up. (not necessarily me BTW)
Sound Rating: 10
I bought it used. It had obviously been well set up by a previous owner. I can't speak for the original setup. My understanding is that Martin guitars come new with a slightly high action. It is assumed that a new guitar should be set up to suit the new owners preferences. The high settings facilitate doing this easily without having to replace a nut or saddle.
Setup Rating: 10
Aside from the scratches and imperfections that were obviously made since the guitar was new, I can find no fault with the fit and finish. The year model I have came with the black plastic pickguard. (my preference would be a tortoise type.)
Appearance Rating: 9
The chrome enclosed tuners work smoothly. The nitro lacquer finish is perhaps not the most durable finish, but it has held up nicely on this example. The bridge pins are plastic, but they seem to be original, and are still in good condition.
Reliability Rating: 10
Martin warrants new guitars to the original owner for lifetime. Since I am not the original owner, the guitar does not have a warranty. Still, Martin customer service has been very helpful and accommodating to my inquiries. No one I know has anything bad to say about Martin customer service.
Customer Service: 10
The bridge pin holes are straight, and the pins are tapered. I would prefer tapered bridge pin holes. I would also prefer a slotted bridge and unslotted bridge pins.
Oh, and the standard 640 thermoplastic case seems substandard for a guitar of this quality.
Components Rating: 9
The Martin HD-28 is probably second only to the D-28 in popularity and sales. Of all the guitars I've owned, I bonded with this one the quickest. This is a lifetime keeper.
Overall Rating: 10
Where Purchased: Guitar Center
Year Purchased: 2005
Price Paid: 1800 ($US)
When I first got this guitar the sound was your typical Martin HD sound great but not a WOW factor.
Now after playing it about every day (no lie) The guitar has really opened up and is one of the best sounding guitars I have ever owned and I get compliments on it everywhere I go.
Sound Rating: 9
This guitar had the standard Martin set up on it when I recieved it. I have sense changed Bridge pins and twiked the truss rod a little.
Setup Rating: 8
This guitar is the standard of which all drednaughts try to mimick. There were no flaws of anykind on the guitar and was in pristine condition. Kudos to Martin on this one!
Appearance Rating: 10
After 3yrs of playing just about every day there is a little wear starting to show. I need a new fret job on 1-5 and 6-10 dressed. The top has started to darken quite nicely looking back at older photos of her.
The tuners which I assume are Martin Pings are starting to slip a little on the 6th string which I think is common.
My only problem is would like to see Martin use a stronger material for their frets.
Reliability Rating: 9
This guitar has a long story behind it which envolves the Guitar Center Kids trying to screw me over but then making it right after I got Martin involved in the process.
Martin will not take crap from anyone when it comes to their products I found this out first hand. When dealing with Martin Customer Service I spoke to a rep. every time who knew my name with out having to tell it to them. They did me right and took care of business the way Professionals do.
Customer Service: 10
The components are your standard Martin items. Nothing weak or cheap about anything. This guitar is very aduquate right out of the box.
Components Rating: 9
Let's face it, ever since Martin envented the Drednaught 28 series it is the most copied guitar on the planet. Everyone wants to copy a martin pre-war guitar just like everyone wants to copy a Gibson Banjo or a Gibson Loar. There are a lot of fine quality guitar makers out there and kudos to them for making a quality product. But at the end of the day you still have a Martin clone.
There are plenty of guitars that sound better out of the box than a new HD-28 if it be a custom guitar or even another Martin. But you will never go wrong with the original design of the HD-28.
I will NEVER get rid of this guitar and I do mean NEVER! It is all I ever need on stage or off.
Overall Rating: 10
Where Purchased: Ponitac Sound and Music
Year Purchased: 1993
Price Paid: $2,000 ($US)
I love this guitar for playing Bluegrass and Southern Gospel both in and out of Church. I tried a D-35 and a couple others that I forget the models now, but this one really had volumn and sound that I know was going to be hard to beat.
Sound Rating: 10
The strings were a little higher than I wanted so after I played it for a while I lower the strings some by sanding down the saddle bridge, now it plays so much easier without losing any volumn.
Setup Rating: 9
I think she's a beauty, the finish is good although after about 10 or 12 years It did get a couple small oil bubbles from the wood on the back side, must not have been all the way dried, but other than that it is great.
Appearance Rating: 9
I have no doubts that this guitar will out last me, I play it a lot and it is showing no sign of wear on the fret wires or anywhere. It is very dependable.
Reliability Rating: 10
Martin says it has a life time warranty as long as you have the paper work for it which I do, and if the problem wasn't casued by negelect. I have never had to contact the company, so I can't say if they would horon their warranty like they say or not.
Customer Service: 9
Everything is great, nothing seems to be cheap or made cheap, nor did I need any upgrades to make it better.
Components Rating: 10
I think Martin is a great guitar, I would recommend them to anyone who is a serious picker, and wouldn't hesitate to buy another one if anything ever happened to this one, "IF" I could find one that sounds as good.
Overall Rating: 10
Where Purchased: Jubilee Music-Fairhope AL
Year Purchased: 2008
Price Paid: 1700+tax ($US)
I play Bluegrass mostly. This guitar is a CANNON! Plus, it should only get sweeter, as the years go by.
Sound Rating: 9
Setup Rating: 9
Appearance Rating: 9
Reliability Rating: 9
The best local dealer around my neck of the woods.
Customer Service: 10
Components Rating: not rated
Well, I got a steal on this guitar, as it was the last '07 model in stock. So I would recommend it for sure at this price, and at a much higher price.
Overall Rating: 9
Terms of Use | Privacy Policy | Privacy Consent (EU/GDPR Only)
Copyright 2026 Flatpicker Hangout. All Rights Reserved.